Welcome to the SOS website
Jun 21st, 2010 by SOS Committee
School audit: speak now or hold your peace
Now is your chance to ask questions, share opinions
on scope of HWRSD operational audit
Joint Meeting
Boards of Selectmen, Hamilton and Wenham
THIS Tuesday, June 22, 7 p.m.
Wenham Town Hall
The operational audit process is moving very quickly.
This Tuesday, the joint boards of selectmen will meet to discuss the Request for Proposal for the $90,000, taxpayer-funded audit of our regional school district. This RFP lays out the scope of work for the project – that is, which aspects of the school district will be examined by an independent auditor.
To read a draft of the RFP, click here.
It appears this Tuesday will be the only time before the RFP is issued that citizens can ask questions, make suggestions or share their expertise.
It’s a busy time of year, but please come Tuesday night and offer your input before the RFP is formally issued.
Thanks
SOS Position on Operational Audit
In June of 2009, the Blue Ribbon Commission (BRC) presented its final report to a Joint Board of Selectman meeting. That report found that the Hamilton Wenham Regional School district had above average cost compared to the cohort districts in the study. The BRC found those above average cost were due to:
- A higher number of teachers and aides, resulting in a lower student/teacher ratio – and not the costs of administration, teacher benefits, facilities operation, maintenance or materials.
- The district’s spending on special education, as a percentage of total spending, is at the top of the peer group for the school year analyzed (2007).
Further evaluation of the numbers by a post BRC group and the DESE found similar results. These results were to be expected given that the community has valued lower class sizes for many years and the school district placed a priority in maintaining lower class sizes. There are also a number of other factors contributing to the situation.
Given their findings the BRC recommend that the two towns and the school district should agree upon and proceed with an RFP for a detailed 3rd Party Review of Instructional Operations at HWRSD to clarify gaps between the district and cohorts.
On March 8, 2010 a citizens’ petition was filed asking for an amendment to the HWRSD Regional Agreement to require an operational audit of the HWRSD. We are aware that counsel for the HWRSD School Committee has advised that an audit can not be mandated through the Regional Agreement since the school committee holds the authority to determine spending and it cannot be required to pay for or implement any recommendations of the audit.
We would urge the Hamilton Board of Selectman to work with the Wenham Board of Selectman, the Regional School Committee, the citizens’ petition supporters, and others supporting an audit to move forward on a third party audit of the district without seeking an amendment to the Regional Agreement.
SOS supports an audit of instructional services as recommended by the BRC in June 2009. If there are other areas which can cost-effectively be included in the audit, and which are reasonable targets for evaluation, SOS will support an expanded scope.
The audit should be funded by the towns of Hamilton and Wenham and be under the direction of a joint committee of representatives of both towns and the Regional School Committee. Once this audit is complete, it should be presented to the School Committee for consideration of whether any recommended changes can and should be implemented and whether any additional audits or studies should be undertaken. The results of the audit should be made publicly available, so voters have an opportunity to understand the results and recommendations of the auditing firm and can seek to influence the School Committee’s decision-making.
With the planned departure of the HWRSD Superintendent at the end of this school year, now is an optimal time to identify areas of change that can benefit the budget and quality of education provided in our schools.
So what did the Blue Ribbon Committee find?
Last year, our towns appointed a Blue Ribbon Committee of citizens to review our schools. The BRC will present its findings and recommendations at a televised Joint Meeting of the Hamilton and Wenham Boards of Selectmen and the School Committee Wednesday, June 17th at 7 p.m. at Wenham Town Hall. Please join us—or watch the presentation on television—to learn about the Committee’s findings.
So what did the BRC find? Briefly, it found there are no more obvious opportunities for significant cost savings in our schools at this time. But it will recommend that the towns hire an educational expert to explore whether efficiencies can be identified in the delivery of instructional services — the only area in which we outspend our peer school districts. The committee also found that our towns’ current system of negotiating the school budget needs improvement.
Attend the meeting—or watch it on TV— to learn more.
Presentation to Town Boards on Wednesday, June 17, 7 P.M., Wenham Town Hall
Have you heard?
Boston Magazine’s School Issue is out which placed HWRHS in the top 25 percent of Boston area schools that “are performing well…while operating efficiently.” Click to view the full set of articles at Boston Magazine
Click to view chart at Boston Magazine Click to download the chart as a spreadsheet
Return here soon for a more in-depth comparison with other schools in our region.
New “Articles” Section
We have created a new section of the website called “Articles“. It will include a number of articles about schools/education as it relates to the Hamilton-Wenham School District. We’re starting off with three articles reprinted from the Boston Globe North edition published last week which deal with the cost of extracurricular fees in our region. There is a link at the top of the page, or you can click this link.
New Report Available
At the request of the Hamilton Board of Selectmen, the Department of Revenue’s Division of Local Services (DLS) has completed a financial management review of the Town of Hamilton. The 30 page report is available at http://www.mass.gov/Ador/docs/dls/mdmstuf/Technical_Assistance/FinMgtRev/Hamilton.pdf (PDF, 166KB)





The Hamilton Wenham School District is seeking to offer a public education that at least meets national averages. Unfortunately, funding of public schools in MA, especially in suburban and rural towns, is currently being born almost exclusively by the residential tax payer. Because of past failed override votes, our selectmen and finance committee advised the school committee that they would not support an aggregate FY 2008 override for the two towns of more than $500K. This amount represented approximately 1/3 of the amount needed to maintain level services with FY 2007. The override passed with record approval levels in Hamilton (57.6%) and high levels in Wenham (73.9%). The schools need more money than our town officials let us approve. This year, we need to make up the difference out of our own private funds. Next year, we need to ensure that the voters get the opportunity to approve appropriate public funding for our public schools.
Lynnette and Jerry Fallon
I hate to admit it, but when I learned that our School District was going to eliminate 22 full time positions this year, and that it added up to 80 since 2002, I seriously considered moving to Essex or Ipswich.
OK, I was half serious; I love our community and I’ve invested too much in it to just walk away. It’s way to disruptive to move, and not cheap; the easy course of action for me was to donate my time to the SOS campaign and my money to the School District!
Tom Rogers
I am a child going into fifth grade at Cutler and I will be directly affected by the teaching change and I am not psyched about transferring! S.O.S, I love your cause and I am trying to start a fund raiser. I donated my own money. My friends might also donate. I am sure no one wants to get moved but the main reason we are donating is so my friend Patrick can come back to Cutler. You see, Patrick went to Scotland for a year for his dad’s business and went to school there. So now he is classified as ‘new’. The new principal is helpful but Patrick still can’t come here without S.O.S.
Michael A
My husband and I are contributing to the Support Our Schools campaign with both our time and our money. We want our children to have the best possible education at our local schools, and feel that the quality of the education provided is being severely jeopardized by all the budget cuts made over the past 4 years. By supporting this effort now we are hoping to restore some of the 22 teaching positions that have been cut this year, and stop the redistricting currently planned for 4th and 5th grade students. It is my fervent hope that our kids (who will be in kindergarten and first grade next year) will get the same quality of education that students got before all these cuts started.
Nancy Peterson and Paul Driscoll
We moved to Hamilton 15 years ago because the Hamilton-Wenham schools were widely considered one of the ten best school systems in the state. We were willing to pay a large premium for our home because we knew that that cost would be returned many times over by the value of the education our children would receive.
Over the past years, we have watched with sadness as our towns have failed to adequately fund our schools and the value of a Hamilton-Wenham education has fallen. Since 2002, we have eliminated the equivalent of eighty full-time teaching positions—a devastating blow to a district this small.
Yes, the override passed but that override was so inadequate that the District still faces a $1,000,000 gap in order to provide the same services it provided last year. Having already cut its teaching staff, the District is forced to increase class-size to achieve the savings its vastly under-funded budget requires it to make.
Next—having cut staff and increased class sizes—our District is forced to trim curriculum. At a time when there is a nation-wide movement to spread the Advanced Placement curriculum, our high school offers very few AP classes. Electives? The High School is cutting music programs, theater programs and any elective class that is not crammed full of students. Languages? As it phases out French, Hamilton-Wenham will earn the distinction of being one of only three districts in the state that offers only one foreign language (Spanish) – and the other two towns in this abysmal category are towns I had never even heard of.
Sports? We are now the only district in Essex County that charges parents a 100% user fee.
Technology? Many of the computers at the High School are so outdated that they cannot support current software. The High School’s computer labs are inadequate and much of its existing software is out of date. There are not enough computers in classrooms. The science labs lack appropriate storage space for chemicals. Even the phone system needs an overhaul.
What can you do? First, give as much as you can to Support our Schools— a private fundraising drive to meet some of the gap in next year’s budget. These funds will all be turned over to the School District to fund budget items according to District’s list of priorities. (Those priorities are listed on the SOS web-page: http://www.hwsos.org). In the first two weeks of fundraising alone, SOS raised close to $200,000, including pledges and matching gifts. Many, many families have given over $1,000 each. Indeed, if each school family gave $295 for each schoolchild, SOS would achieve its goal of raising $600,000 towards the district’s $1,000,000 budget gap. However, every dollar counts and high participation levels will send the message that we need our government to adequately fund our schools.
Yes, we should be deeply concerned when there is a need to ask private donors to fund a public school’s operating budget. However, once programs are lost, they take years to rebuild. The devastation next year’s cuts will otherwise bring means that every family in our District—and everyone in our community who cares about education or our towns—should support the SOS effort. (Make checks payable to the Hamilton Wenham Regional School District and send them to SOS at P.O. Box 2445, South Hamilton, MA 01982. SOS needs the money by June 15th to meet the District’s hiring schedule.)
What else can you do? Put the “public” back in public education. Private funding is a short-term bandage that cannot heal the bleeding that is happening in our District. Insist that our town leaders adequately fund our schools. SOS’s effort addresses immediate needs but cannot address the larger issues facing our schools or all of the severe cuts in curriculum and staff throughout our District. And waiting for the state or federal government to fund schools in Hamilton-Wenham—where the median home value is a hefty $540,000—is like waiting for the tooth fairy to arrive.
The excellence for which our District was known took decades to build. If we let that excellence vanish now, we may never gain it back. We have lost too much already.
Marie P. Buckley
I, for one, am sick and tired of those high paid teachers. Their hefty salaries are driving up taxes, and they only work nine or ten months a year! It’s time we put things in perspective and pay them for what they do: baby-sit! We can get that for less than minimum wage. That’s right I would give them $3.00 dollars an hour and only the hours they worked, not any of that silly planning time. That would be $23.76 a day (7:45 AM to 3:00 PM with 22 min. off for lunch). Each parent should pay $23.76 a day for these teachers to baby-sit their children.
Now, how many do they teach in a day. . maybe 23? So that’s $23.76 X 23 = $546.48 a day. But remember they only work 180 days a year! I’m not going to pay them for any vacations. Let’s see that’s $546.48 X 180 = $98,336.40 (Hold on! My calculator must need batteries!)
What about those special teachers or the ones with master’s degrees? Well, we could pay them minimum wage just to be fair. Round it off to $7.00 an hour. That would be $7 times 6.92 hours times 23 children times 180 days = $200,541.60 per year. Wait a minute, there is something wrong here! There sure is!!!!!
Dear SOS Committee members,
It is with some reluctance that my husband and I enclose a donation to the 2007 Save Our Schools campaign. We love our school system, and it is most certainly a worthy cause. However, having had children in the regional system since 2001, we see a disturbing trend forming.
As you know, this is the second time in the last five years that SOS has quickly raised private funds to “save the day” and prevent the loss of a number of public school programs and services in response to under-funding by the towns of Wenham and Hamilton. While the goal is laudable, this is surely a short-sighted way to fund our schools. How can we continue to attract and retain high-quality teachers and administrators when their positions are at risk year after year? How will our high school maintain its accreditation when we cannot guarantee funds to maintain the facilities from year to year? And yet, by not pressuring our town administrators, school committee, and fellow citizens to come up with long-term solutions to our budget woes and then “coming to the rescue” at the last minute with private funds, we encourage the trend to continue.
Several emails and letters that we have received in the last few weeks from SOS speak of addressing the immediate needs now, and working towards a better solution later. This year, let’s make sure there IS a later. Please honor these donations by remaining active long after we’ve plugged the hole in the dike. Continue to keep us informed of SOS news and we will help! Encouraging the school board to present a more inclusive budget in future years is a start, but it won’t fix the bottom line, which is clearly a lack of town revenue. Many of us can afford higher tax rates, but many, especially seniors, cannot. And I believe there are some sticky ethical issues regarding private funding of public school systems. This is a district-wide problem that requires participation of the whole district to solve it!
I’ve read that the town of Hamilton is paying $2500 to work with Northeastern University to examine ways to bring businesses into town without ruining the rural character that we all appreciate so much. Could Wenham be involved in something similar? Expanding our commercial tax base would be a boon to the town treasuries, and I personally would feel better about donating funds for a similar collaborative project, if money is not available in the town coffers, than I do about donating funds directly to the public schools. It may not solve the entire problem, but it would be a start.
Funding our wonderful school system is going to be expensive and problematic for the foreseeable future. Together we can demand long-range planning NOW and stop settling for the last minute, “let’s wait and see” approach.
In closing we thank all of you for the hard work you have done to save our schools once again. Our towns owe each of you a debt of gratitude, and we want you to know how much our family, in particular, appreciates what you’ve done this year.
Very truly yours,
Kim Aalfs and Chris Needham